French Vanilla, Butter Pecan, Chocolate Deluxe
By now, most folks have heard about the uproar in Detroit where a promoter decided to throw a party where Lightskinneded womenses and Libras got in free. If you haven’t, please do read the article.
*smoke break*
You back? Well, welcome!
I’ve heard numerous individuals discussing this story and lots of folks have harassed this young man for his colorism and ignorance in deciding to add fuel to the color cocophony in this country by further dividing an already divided race of people who’ve been hurt enough by white people’s focus on skin color. Why–oh why–would we do it to our own.
Poor fellow. He’s gone and cancelled his party and listened to the cries of the men and women who speak out against such atrocities in our community.
They should all eat a dick and die.
From the heart.
It’s amazing how stories and intentions can get totally misconstrued and fucked the fucked up through the little game we call “Telephone”. Hell, read the headline to the linked article. I first heard about this through some club promoters in DC telling me about this “light-skinned party” in Detroit and how this guy was throwing a party for lightskinned people. No mention of the Lightskinned FREE that night or that it was a party for everybody. We actually then engaged in a discussion of what kind of self-hate party we could throw in DC.
We landed on “Light and White in White” — a party where only lightskinned people dating white people could come through as long as they were wearing white. We’d serve fried chicken martini’s with watermelon slices. It’s amazing the ignorance that’s possible when you get enough like-minded ignant motherfuckers in the same place. Viva la imagination!
Anyway, upon further review, it turns out this promoter, DJ Lish, was planning on doing upcoming parties in a series, if you will, that would include dark skinned and the nebulous “ain’t light but ain’t dark” or better known as the “caramel” sisters.
IGNANT SIDENOTE: You know we have too much food in America when Black folks take to describing our color in food terms. I ain’t never met an African who refers to him or herself as a Chocolate drop. Perhaps coicidentally, there’s some starving ass motherfuckers over there too. You get to calling yourself Choco-Latay and you just might get cannibalised. Too. much. food. in. America.
Let’s delve a little shall we? Was this fellow slightly misguided? Perhaps. Any time you decide to throw skin tone into the mix with los Negros, you’re welcoming criticsm. Face it, we’re still a bunch of people who are psychologically and literally paying for our God (or whoever you pray to) given blessings. And because of that, skin tone issues are largely a sparkplug for outrage.
Hmm, fuck that.
Let me rephrase this (which is the source of this dude’s problem). Ever since the slavery days, lightskinned and dark skinned folks have been at odds. Sometimes blatantly, sometimes latently. Think about the barbs thrown our way. People ALWAYS resort to using somebody’s skin tone when making disparaging comments.
“Lightskinned bitch thinks she’s better than me!”
“Dark skinned motherfucker lookin’ like midnight!”
And we wonder why white people do it.
Thing is, implicit in both of those statements lies the problem. There’s a clear ideology about how skin tone plays into society. Light is right and dark is, well…dark. And we’ve all bought into it in some way shape or form. It’s a sad state of affairs but its unfortunately the state we live in. It’s like living in Montana when you know California exists.
It’s like rain on your wedding day. Oh wait, that’s actually ironic.
Or not. Am I the only person who got slightly peeved that she called so many things that weren’t actually ironic, ironic? She kept noting coincidences, not ironies. Though I suppose saying, “Now isn’t it a coincidence” doesn’t have the same punch. But I digress.
Dark skinned people constantly get the short end of the stick. And it sucks. But you know, that’s not really lightskinned people’s fault. It’s white people’s fault, but much like Black-on-Black crime…
…we STAY robbing the wrong people.
Yes, Black people stay losing.
So here comes DJ Lish, who from my perspective only made one real mistake.
He threw the wrong party first. But let’s think about this. How many of you people are party promoters? And for those who’ve been doing it for a while, how difficult is it to come up with something that actually draws people in? Promoting sucks. There are really not that many things you can do as a promoter to really draw folks in short of random gimmicks. Enter DJ Lish.
And he had a good idea. It’s a winner, a gimmick catered to the very women most men harp on in the media. Light chicks.
“…and all the wavey light skinned girls is loving me now…” ~ Jay - Z “December 4th”
Wrong or right, it’s true. And I’m sure a lot of light skinned reading chicks probably hate the lightskinned-points they get, but they sure don’t mind the attention. But the point is promoters need gimmicks to draw people in. Promotion is an ugly game.
So he picked the Light and Libra party. Bad move bucko, but not a bad idea. You should have just started with the Sexual Chocolate first because niggas hate color schemes, but don’t mind Chocolate as much as we mind Light-skinned preference. We actually love it when people of darker-hue receive recognition.
Read: India.Arie’s fanbase.
I think the outrage wouldn’t have been as loud for that party. Color me stupid and call me Renee but I think that our color issues intra-racially are far more skewed towards wanting to knock light-skinned “bitches” down a peg or two. So of course, any party that celebrates and benefits a woman’s light-skinnededness is going to catch hell. And the purveyor is going to catch wreck.
I wish this DJ would call me because I’d love to tell him not to listen to the motherfuckers who called for his head and have decided that he realizes he was wrong and should work on being a better person.
Fuck them.
Is he naive? Clearly, he thought he was just going to throw a party that allowed light-skinned chicks to gain entry free one night, but what he got was national attention and articles and phone calls. Playing with skin-tone is playing with fire, bucko. You can still play that game but you have to play it smarter. It’s actually a win-win. You throw that first Sexual Chocolate party and you can’t NOT throw the other two.
That’s how you stay winning.
But this dude has been reprimanded and scoffed at and I think that’s total bullshit. Not a bad idea, just bad judgement and decision-making on his part. Intra-race issues will be present forever, but everything ain’t as terrible as we want it to be.
Except the “Light and White and White” Party…there’s just no excuse for that one.
Word to Al Sharpton.

October 17th, 2007 12:59
Not only will I agree that I hate the ‘light-skin’ points I get, I will up you one and admit that I hate the ‘good hair’ points, as well.
I get it, it’s about preference, and there has to be something physical that initially attracts one to another … but after that, I’d like to think that I’d be found desirable for traits other than those that were genetically pre-destined.
Eh, whatever. Once, when I told a guy I was dating that I was a toasty color, he told me: “If my toast came out your color, I’d return my appliance.”
Hey!
Thanks for the California love, and you killed me with the random Alanis Morissette reference.
October 17th, 2007 13:25
I’m surprised, but I agree with your assessment. I had the same thought not when I heard the headline, but when I read the REST of the story (which for some reason, a lot people seemed to have looked over, lol). I think this guy had an ingenious idea but he was naive in grossly underestimating Black folks’ deep-seeded issues with skin tone. I’m going to go ahead and say also that in addition to being naive, he’s probably not very bright either cuz Duh, OF COURSE he should have started with the dark-skinned ladies, who were undoubtedly the bulk of the complainers he encountered. OF COURSE they would be offended after likely a lifetime of insinuations that they were somehow inferior to their lighter-skinned sisters. Seems like he would have the foresight to consider that. But then, we’ve already established he’s not very bright so oh well, lol. Btw, I think his apologies came off quite sincere so I pretty much give him a pass and chalk it up to a silly, silly mistake.
Good post.
October 17th, 2007 14:35
When I heard it was a series, I was like “ok”. Not as bad. Still dumb. If he started with chocolate no one would have cared.
October 17th, 2007 22:48
I have no real comment except I want to call you stipid Renee.
October 18th, 2007 14:57
Dude, the irony of the song is that its not ironic. Missed that much?
October 18th, 2007 15:36
LMAO. As soon as I read the article I thought to myself, “If this guy had just chosen the dark-skinned girl party first there would have been no outcry.” I agree with you, that was the only bad move on his part.
I really enjoy your blog. Your perspective on things is always on the money as far as I am concerned.
October 18th, 2007 16:03
perhaps i did. then again, maybe i’m not as smart or as deep as other people, which i’m okay with.
then again, that still doesn’t make much sense to me.
like isn’t it ironic that none of this shit is ironic? but hell, whatever…i’ll be slow. i’ll be dat.
October 18th, 2007 16:04
thanks imani. i appreciate that.
and T…its morehouse homecoming this weekend…guess who’s gonna be in the A?!!! Me that’s who.
October 19th, 2007 05:35
I know! My friend (who graduated the same year as you ironically) just called me the other day and told me he’s coming down and wants to hang out. I’ll give you my info (via e-mail).
October 21st, 2007 21:57
I agree that the flack would not have been as bad if he had started with the “chocolate” women, but I don;t neccesarily believe that he was actually gonna have one. Furthermore, I have to disagree with the commenter who said that dark-skinned women made up the bulk of the complainers. Anybody with half a brain as gagging when they read this. This is some sick shit and I would have said that if he had “A Blacker The Berry” party.
Yeah, the party would have drawn people in: a bunch of sick, miguided and stoopid light-skinned girls and a rack of color-struck, culturally unaware men (most of whom would have been dark-skinned, I’d be willing to bet). I’m almost tempted to say “let them Negroes have each other. Identify yourself, Sambos, so the reasonable Black folk don’t get tied up in your foolishness”.
A few years ago, I had a dude tell me that when he thinks of an attractive woman, he automatically thinks of a light-complexioned woman. Sure, there are some “fine chocolate girls”, but most REALLY fine chicks are light. Dude telling me this was the color of that dark furniture from Ikea that says “Black Brown”, but when you bring it home and set it next to your brown furniture, you look mix-matchy. That dark.
“but don’t mind Chocolate as much as we mind Light-skinned preference. We actually love it when people of darker-hue receive recognition.”
Great point, though I think India’s success is because she is, in fact, beautiful and talented. Saying you prefer light-skin is taboo, and saying you love “sexy chocolate” is considered a Black Power move. I think it’s all sick.